Publisher Profile

EnigmAcoustics Sopranino Electrostatic Super Tweeter Review

By: |

 EnigmAcoustics Sopranino Electrostatic Super Tweeter Front View

These great looking little wonders have been making big news on the Audio Show Circuit. How couldn’t they be with someone as enthusiastic and welcoming as Mr. Wei Chang demonstrating them, but it takes more than enthusiasm to make a real buzz. It takes something you can really hear.

My first opportunity to hear this demo was at the 4th California Audio Show in August. The EnigmAcoustic demo setup was the same as at the Newport show. The Sopraninos were mounted above the Magico V3s. The rest of the system consisted of Pass Labs electronics, the Light Harmonics Da Vinci DAC and an Apple Mac Mini. One thing for sure: a very revealing system.

The demonstration was as simple as could be; they would play a selection on the system without the Sopranino super tweeters and then with them. The difference wasn’t difficult to hear, no so called “trained ears” were needed. I’m not new to super tweeters; I lived with and loved the Murata ES103a Spherical Super Tweeters for several years. I used them with the Audio Note AN-E speakers and the Ikonoklast speakers and with the same Wavac EC-300B amp I have now. I loved how my system sounded better with the Murata. It sounded more like music, and it sounded clearer, yet the super tweeters did not make the system brighter.  They did not add sparkle to the top-end, and they did not make my system sound super-detailed or etched. So, I arranged to get the Sopraninos in to review with several different speaker.

Design

EnigmAcoustics refer to their super tweeter as the SBESL or Self-Biased ElectroStactic Loudspeaker. This refers to its being the first, according to them and as far as I know, purely passive electrostatic tweeter with no need of external bias. In other words, they don’t have to be plugged into an electrical outlet. The method invented by EnigmAcoustics makes it possible to permanently implant charges on a non-conductive film with special molecular structure serving as charge holder. They have come up with a way to implement the theoretical idea of replacing the diaphragm of an electrostatic speaker with a permanently charged film, culminating in the complete eradication of the costly and power hungry active bias circuitry. Though with this first product I don’t see where they saved much money, it is nonetheless quite an achievement and I would love to hear a full-range electrostatic speaker using this new technology.

There is more to the new design than just not having to plug them into an AC outlet. It is absolutely critical to maintain a minimum openness and thickness on the stators surface when allowing sound waves generated from the vibrating diaphragm to penetrate through them. The rigidity of stators is required to be kept to a minimum in order to lessen any undesired vibration that would result in distortion. Also, the effective area of stator surface must be proportional to the exerting push/pull electric force on a diaphragm. All of these factors are constantly in conflict with one another, which adversely affect, either directly or indirectly, the overall performance of the ESL.

EnigmAcoustic says their new technology deals with these issues by making the stators out of a fiberglass substrate for optimal balance of rigidity and thickness. To finish it off, the substrate is covered with copper for best conductivity and for maximum openness, while maintaining strong and sustainable electric force.

2 Responses to EnigmAcoustics Sopranino Electrostatic Super Tweeter Review


  1. federalist says:

    Would these work with a speaker around 95-96 dB sensitivity?

  2. hifitommy says:

    for nearly $4k , that is WAY too much money for the results. i added a philips clear plastic dome tweeter to my stacked dyancoa a25s back in the day and crossed them over at 10kHz. the results i garnered was a beautiful, airy, more extended top and an overall better transient response to the speaker and a more extended low end (perhaps that part is psychoacoustic).

    after listening to them for a month or two, i thought about how some speaker designers reverse the phase of the tweeter to the woofer to eliminate the hole in the middle. i figured there was nothing to lose by inverting the phase of my philips supertweeter (for the a25, extending the response above 12k IS a supertweeter in that system). WOW, it opened up even more so it was a fortuitous experiment.

    were the sopranino HALF its price, it would still be a stretch for the results. another factor is that the level is only adjustable in two steps, not continuously variable or with about four level selections. i think it has three xover pints too, which should be adequate.

    i still have to hear a well conducted listening session utilizing theses tweeters. one dealer i attended a session with wouldn’t turn the tweeters off at all except once which resulted in better sound without them. this was with the carver amazing full range ribbon. i can’t afford them anyway but i would like to feel like i had heard a proper demo.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popups Powered By : XYZScripts.com